The first settlement in the area was called Pokerville, and was located about a mile or so downstream of the present town of Plymouth. The camp was established around 1852, and as water was scarce, and the placers stingy, the camp kind of faded away as the miners drifted upstream to a new site, a site which became known as Puckerville in 1855. This new camp proved to be more prosperous than the old, but not by much. A number of claims, with names such as Southerland, the Aden, and the Simpson, were located about a mile east of town and as the years went by they helped the camp hold its own, neither booming nor busting, but surviving.
Nothing of much excitement occurred in Pokerville or the surrounding area until 1871 when Alvinza Hayward purchased an interest in the Aden-Simpson, or “Plymouth Mine”. Hayward was a sharp mining man, having made a fortune in his mines in Sutter Creek and the Comstock Lode. He must have seen something worthwhile in Plymouth. Mining gold takes money, and Hayward certainly had that. He authorized the construction of a new stamp mill and began more work on the claim itself, extensive exploration, and deeper mining. One of the results of this capital outlay was an increase in jobs. More jobs needed more men and more men needed more places to spend their wages. Hotels, saloons, stores, and other places where men like to spend money were quickly constructed.
Pokerville grew, expanding to take care of these needs. And when the post office was established in September of 1871, with John J. Ekel as the postmaster, the place was known as Plymouth. When did the name change and for what reason? No one knows the answers to these and other questions. The name “Plymouth” appeared perhaps for the first time in 1856. It was applied to a quartz mill location on the north bank of Dry Creek, about a mile or so from Puckerville.
Meanwhile, Hayward kept buying up ground and claims and by 1878 the Phoenix Mine – formerly the Plymouth was producing $30,000 to $50,000 a month in gold. They sold the Phoenix that year, including its mill and a few of its ditches, to a New York corporation for $2 million. Renamed the Empire Mine, it was consolidated with a number of other claims in 1883, becoming the Plymouth Consolidated Mining Company, which operated until 1947.
During the 1850s, the settlements of Plymouth, and Pokerville grew up side by side on a dry flat. Plymouth survives now as an agri-center with an emphasis on the Shenandoah Valley vineyards to the east of town. Pokerville has vanished. There is very little in Plymouth to remind you of the gold rush days. The headframe and tailings from the Plymouth Consolidated mines, which produced over $13 million in gold, are still evident.